well im late to the game here, but my vote officially put all 3 choices dead EVEN!!! heh sorry.
You know me, and you know my bias... MS6! Mileage isnt hardly different than MS3, same engine... so it is mostly HOW you drive it. the MS6 potentially gets worse mileage due to the AWD and heaver car, but like the MS3, it can be grandma driven just like any other i4 engine to get decent mileage. In the end your key words were "but what i really want" is an MS3. So you may become unsatisfied with the MS6 after a few months or so... As far as MS3 choices, 100% would say go with CWP!!!! they arent nearly as common as the black ones... CWP is sho shexy!!
Here is my opinion when it comes to final choice:
- If you baby your cars, and KNOW that you can handle premium prices & upkeep, than you would be able to manage a turbo car.
- If you are unsure if you can afford the premium gas and regular upkeep of a turbo car, might want to stick with N/A.
- concerning both routes and what you can objectively afford you also need to decide how long you think you'll be keeping the car, and if it is long term, will you be SATISFIED with your choice for the long haul (i.e. wishing from day one you got a turbo, or wishing after a few weeks you got better mileage)
- Aesthetically, and in your personal opinion, which car looks better? - of course a huge deciding fact... which in the end is a big part to your decision.
lol i talk too much.
hope that gives you a bit mroe to think about. (most of which was prolly already talked about)
cheers