I think I'll end up with the Xice3 in 195/55-15. I'm hoping that given how light the 2 is they aren't too horribly mushy performance-wise when it's not snowing.
I could make the old stock tires scream, these new X-ice's just make a rubbing noise when I take a hard corner. They seem to be a lot softer but they stick to dry or wet pavement like glue!