I traded my 2009 Honda Civic with just shy of 100K miles. I liked the Civic, not an exciting car, but got me where I needed and was very reliable. I thought about buying a used SUV as a second car because I wanted more space for things like bikes, trips to home depot, etc. But decided after seeing what I could get in trade for my Civic and the fact I had wanted a Mazda for a while, that the CX-5 satisfied my needs for extra space while managing to be a fun, fuel efficient daily driver. It has pretty much held up to that ideal and while there are a few things that Honda did better, but the CRV just didn't appeal to me. I've read about a few people go from Civic's to CX-5s. My theory is as a single, 30 something male, the CR-V just seems to frumpy to me, where the CX-5 has just enough youthfulness to have it edge out the CR-V during my purchase decision. Another consideration during my purchase was the Ford Escape and I still think about it. Liked the interior more than the CX-5; interior lighting, pano sunroof, subwoofer, better nav, etc. The CX-5 has the Escape on exterior looks, MPG, and handling. I guess it is 6 of one, half dozen of the other. Good chance I would have gotten the Escape if the dealer hadn't been so annoying.