They are significantly different. Neither are perfect. Ideally we'd have something in between the two. A little firmness from the CX-50 (but not as firm) and without the delay from the CX-5 brakes. Overall, I prefer the CX-5 brakes, but I don't prefer the delay.I don't notice much (if any) difference between the 'softness' of our CX-5 vs CX-50. Also, people complain about the CX-50 brakes too,