StuttersC said:I disagree. The 323 GTX is a classic example of a stout motor in an all-wheel-drive car that handled plenty of power, and the car over-all was a solid competitor.
And the Mazdaspeed Miata is another stout motor. Turbo Miatas have handled serious power levels for a long time with zero reliability issues.
I think the collar Mazda wears is semi-self imposed and mostly imposed by the Ford monster on it's back. If the Miata out-powered the new 'Stang, Ford would be mad. If the MSP out-powered the then SVT Focus, we would have a problem. The same thing follows suit with the Mazdaspeed 6. The Fusion is supposed to be the big dog, not the up start Mazda.
Although I agree with some of what you are saying, you have somewhat changed the argument here. The past doesn't mean much right now. I'm talking about the present. What I see is a Mazdaspeed 6 having tuning issues, and needing constant reflashes to try and keep this power consistent. I have owned an STI previously, and the car has a good deal more hp, yet even when it first came out in summer of 2003, it had no reflashes, no tuning issues, loss of power, and runs superbly, even modified in Stage 2. The de-tuned Legacy GT has the power of the Speed 6, but power gains are very easy on that car. The potential is far greater right now, and I believe the reliability is far greater as well. The AWD system itself is more durable. If you wanna disagree that's fine.

Mazda may have some nice performing cars, but if you think this 2.3 turbo engine is advanced enough right now for them to reliably make a 300+HP bone stock Speed 6, capable of adding 50whp reliably, you are kidding yourself. They have to play catchup. Yes, they detuned the MS vehicles in the past, but they had to in order for it to handle modifications reliably. They can't put out a high hp car thats ready to instantly handle 50 more WHP like Subaru and Mitsubishi can do. The Speed 6 is not purposely de-tuned. Perhaps in a few years 260-270hp in that engine will be de-tuned.
I wouldn't trust my Speed 6 if I added 50whp, but I would my former STI in a heartbeat. We shall see if they can compete with Subaru and Mitsubishi. I'd love to see them produce a car to compete with the STi and EVO, but I just don't think they can right now.

Last edited: