If you have to take him to court, or even if he tries to be cheap with a rental, just make sure you get something you'd be happy driving for a couple of days, if it took that long...And I would definately recommend a new fender. If they pop it out, it still could get bumped and knocked back in..I had a girlfriend one time with a spot on her car's fender like that. If you barely even touched it, it would get pushed in, and you had to jack up the car, and remov the fender liner to pop it back out.