I bought my car last September, and I've been keeping my gas mileage on a spreadsheet since I bought the car and my current average is 24-25 MPG. But the range is from 20MPG (during the winter) to 29MPG (in the summer). My car was real sluggish during the winter - especially when the air temp hits < 10 degrees. But I've switched to Mobil 1 5w30 and hope to see some improvement this winter.
Note that this summer I've averaged 27-29MPG just about every week. I do about 20 miles/day of city driving, and am on the highway very little.
I shift at 3000 rpm in first through fourth, and into fifth at 2500 rpm. I can keep up with traffic, and rarely rev past 5000 rpm when I'm passing. Another factor is I usually only press the gas about halfway down when accelerating.
There's such a wide range of mileage out there, because there are a lot of factors affecting your gas mileage. To name a few: how hard you press the accelerator, how high you rev the engine, how much air pressure is in your tires, what type of traffic you drive in, the ambient air temperature, road conditions, etc. Some of these you can't control (road conditions, air temp, etc), while you can control how you drive. I don't always shift as I mentioned above, I like to rev my engine and some days I will really wind it out - but that's not every day. In a typical week, maybe 1 1/2 days are driving hard, the other I'm pretty calm.
I plan on having this car in 8 years, so I can't abuse it too much now.
Just my .02.