I already have a lawyer on this. I am just waiting for their final decision on whether they are going to pay for it or not.
BTW...the reason it is suspect to them is not because of the fact that I got a new car a week before they found my old one. That is really silly, what good would that do me knowing I was still in possession of the title on the old car. It was still mine at that point. The real reason is because the police report says I was asleep at the time of the theft, but I said I was awake. (Which I was!) This simple error is causing all the problems and it may be enough to prevent the company from paying...
...and someone asked earlier who I am with.... MetLife. (The second highest ranking insurance company for customer satisfaction... Ironic, don't you think?)