That is a bad way to calculate. 14.5 Gallons is the capacity, unless you are driving the car dry (which is a no-no), you can't use that as your basis. Most people claim the gas light comes on at 12 to 12.5 Gallons of fuel (2-2.5 remaining). I'd actually track it by hand. Fill your tank up all the way (don't top off). Drive it down, go to the same station/pump and fill it up again, don't top off. Figure the miles you traveled (this is what your trip is for!), and divide it by the amount of gas you just put in.
Adjusting your calculations above, you are probably getting closer to 23 and 16 respectively. I've seen as low as 23 in my automatic, but never have I really gone below 20. It averages 26 since I got the car.
Tire pressure, weather, and seasonal fuel mixes can play a huge part in your mileage. Not to mention driving habits and engine/drivetrain conditions.