Some would say that without EGR you'll run lean and have EGT and detonation problems. Best arguement I can make to support that is that our cars run rich, expecting to get some gas back through the exhaust.
If you have standalone management, no problem, but I'd be careful with the stock ECU.
Also, it should be noted that the EGR is not active at idle or WOT, so you shouldn't see a decrease in performance while using the EGR.
I have a wideband 02 sensor. Car does not run leaner at all with the egr gone. Also our cars do not run rich. 14.7 is as perfect as you can get, and thats what ours do pretty much dead on.
Maybe one person has a "standalone" everybody else has whats known as a "piggyback". They just modify the signal to the injectors and spark plug timing. They dont touch egr sensors. I blocked off my egr at aboput 3000 miles on my car. Did not have a turbo for another yr or so and then did not get the emanage for about 1 1/2yrs after that. Car ran fine from the very begining with no egr valve. (took the damn cats off too!)
And lastly you are correct the egr does not open at idle, but im 90% sure it does at WOT and in the upper throtle position. That way you supposedly dont notice when its dumping that crappy ass, oxygen deleted, carbon monoxide, soot filled crap back into your motor.
If it's clogged up your car won't run, so your saying that you don't need it. How does one then take it off and not use it, or are you suggesting something else?
when its "clogged up" it just means there is soot and carbon under the valve seat (the same crap is also building up in your intake and on and around your intake valves) and it wont close, so you are always putting exhaust back into your intake.
The easiest way for most to "take it off" is to take it off, make a new gasket for it with NO HOLES in it other than the bolt holes. Then just put it back on. Then you dont have to worry about making a plate to cover the hole, and a plug for the mani, if you take it off completely. If yours is not clogged where it does not seal, but you just want to make it stop opening and letting that crap in your motor, just unplug the wire harness plugged into it.
Im at 40,000 now so 37000 miles with no egr, and I'll send you a pic next time i can, my intake is spotless inside.