Dunlop 3D or Pirelli Scorpion Winter?

[Monterra]

I think I finally decided on 17s after seeing pics of 16s for my winter setup. This meant going 235/65 to get a performance winter tire.
Q1: Any possible issues/concerns with these fitting? TR won't guarantee but I don't think it will be an issue...
Q2: Pretty much same price, both H rated- which one would you go with?

thanks!

 

[costermonger]

They'll fit. The speedo will be out by less than 2%.

Why not get a 225/65 though? Lots of choice, and narrow > wide for winter tires.

 

[Monterra]

No good performance winter option in 225/65, but I'd consider the T rated Conti Extreme Winter in that size