Update on using oil:
Bad idea kids... the squeak came back in about a week and a half.
Went to PepBoy's and picked up some Silicone Lubricant (black spray can, don't recall a brand name) and redid the process... we'll see how long this lasts. Now for the grease, should I be looking for a tube with grease? Or the spray can? The fella at PepBoy's looked at me like I had a dildo on my forehead when I asked for silicone grease, then pointed me in the direction of this spray silicone lubricant I picked up, which was parked right next to the WD-40. We'll see I geuss.
Good times. (smoke)