They, according to PA law, would have to buy the car back at full price. It would be tough to go lemon on the MP3 because of a lot of our milages though...I remember reading the law, and its very tough to do (corporate america in the lawmakers pocket), plus, if you get a lemon law lawyer, it almost doesn't work out for you because you have to end up paying the lawyer so much of what the car company give you for the car. I could be completely wrong, but this is what I think I remember...getting it fixed would be the best solution, because I still love the car for everything else it does and is.