It was APR's own exhaust that I was speaking of in my earlier post. (it also happened to be one of the highest performing exhausts available for the 1.8T, but it was also the most expensive, so cost was not much of a factor in their design) So obviously 3" was a bit of overkill since APR has a reputation for some of the most comprehensive engine research for aftermarket VW mods. So yes, our engines are slightly larger, but they are also pushing less boost, so I think 2.5" would probably be fine, unless you are planning to strap a larger turbo onto your poor block. I guess my point remains that bigger is not always better.