I used to own a truck (2007 Ford Explorer 4.6L V8 4wd, a BOF truck/SUV) and averaged 14-15 MPG in nearly identical driving condtions (apples to apples comparison).
This sucks, because I bought this car solely based on accepting the fact that it's gutless but gets fantastic fuel economy.
I goose the gas here and there,
You have to go beyond 'accepting' it and embrace it to get better mpg. It is really too easy to try to pull more performance out of the little 4 cylinder and that sacrifices a lot of economy quite quickly. Reset the average mpg and drive smoothly for awhile and then step on it to pass a couple cars and watch the reading drop. It seems to be about a 9 to 1 ratio of how much you have to just baby the throttle to get back that one moment of not babying it.
That will have a noticeable impact quick quickly on the mpg even it it is just here and there. I've done that and seen mine drop more than I'd like.
I just wish it didn't require so much effort to hit those stated MPG numbers. Other than that, loving the car.
I'm getting 24.7 mpg according to the computer. My average speed us about 28mph and I only have 500 miles in my odometet. I'm mostly doing local highways and maybe 30 - 40 miles total in the parkway.I have the AWD GT with 2.0 lt engine. I would imagine that I would be getting a much lower mpg if I had the 2.5. Lt engine.
I have the AWD w/automatic tranny also and I'm getting better than the stated EPA numbers without any real effort. In fact, my mixed driving exceeds the EPA HWY rating. I just drive with the flow of traffic and look ahead so I can get off the gas when needed instead of gassing it into a red light and then needing to brake hard. I consider this common sense driving, not hypermiling. And this is with full on winter driving (mostly in the mountains) and with snow tires. My mileage is actually better than that reported by Fuelly (below) because I enter the odometer readings directly without a correction factor - my CX-5 with 225/65/17 snow tires under reports the distance traveled by about 2.3% If your odometer is also under reporting the true distance you may be getting better MPG than you think. But a Honda Acura with a manual transmission will crush a SUV with AWD and automatic every time. SUV's have a lot of compromises when it comes to efficiency of motion and if economy is your number one consideration you should ask yourself why you "need" a SUV (and one with automatic AWD at that).
Personally, I'm super pleased with the real world economy I'm seeing under far less than ideal conditions.