i had a previous gen R32 for a while. that was a wonderful car, but the performace for the money was sad.
i've driven the new R32 and I like it in some ways, but not in other ways. the DSG tranny is overrated imo. i'm a big fan of low-end torque as the R32 has, but the DSG tranny doesn't let people use it too well. let's say you're driving in 2nd gear at 1800 rpm's, then you slam on the throttle. you'd expect the car (technically being a manual) to stay in gear and let it climb. however, the DSG tranny in both auto and manual modes forces an downshift....lame.
as for the dsg's abillity to hold torque; i've seen new R32's with turbo conversions. of course the dual clutches in the dsg had to be upgraded, but the transmissions seem to hold together pretty well.
the previous gen R32 had approx 240 hp stock. the new one has 250 hp....? wake up VW, this car needs at least another 40 hp over the previous gen.
the exhaust sound in the old R32 is, by far, more delightful than in the new R32. the new exhaust has a noticeably higher pitch and, at some rpms, sounds somewhat like the Audi A3's 3.2 V6..which is to say, nothing spectacular.
the interior of the R32 is a big dissapointment on some levels. i'll give it to VW for added approx 2x the amount of rear leg room for passengers and simply giving the cabin an overall larger feel. however, the R32's interior should be exclusive. the old R32 had seats from god; they were unavailable in any other vehicle from the factory. the R32 gets the GTI's seats with an R32 logo....lame again. the leather is more gray than black; i prefer a straight black leather. and the overall feel of the interior is near identical to a GTI's.
there's the price too. yes, they start at $33k. however, i have yet to find a dealership within 100 miles of me that hasn't thrown a $5k markup on that. $38k, you say...for what comes down to a golf? i'll pass....and wait for a BMW 135i.
the kicker? my co-worker has a new white R32 (white, btw, looks GREAT) and drives in 60% highway and 40% city traffic. he returns, on average, 16 mpg.
now that's plain sad for a car that can't cover the 1/4 in under 14 seconds, repeatedly.
best performance car? no. even at $33k, i'd rather go for used 3 series or an audi A3, with some solid performance mods (ESPECIALLY AN LSD!)
-JR