The controversy behind Octane is as misleading as things can get...No two seperate engines with similar boost will have the same octane requirements...But don't look at it that way...Octane is generally simply a chemical that allows gasoline to behave differently in combustion...It basically creates a higher detonation threshold by helping to "buffer" and control the expanding mixture...SRT 4 engines have different static compression ratio's...run different quench area dynamics...and are pushing radically different amounts of air through by different turbo's...The tuning, which is the most important part out of all of this, is also different...
My guess also is the cooling benefits created by Dogde's oil squirter routing too...It can be said to run cooler under boost most likely than our dinosaur...which will allow it to run higher boost safely with a lesser octane'd fuel...
And to beat the dead horse a little more...The SRT 4 uses a brand new 2.4L mill, that also sits in the PT Turbo GT models...The EVO uses the 14+ year old mitsu designed 4G63, that still kicks more than adequate ass...Nothing is interchangeable, and they are completely different...
EDIT: didn't realize there were 3 pages of s*** here...thought there was only one...Someone else pointed out the SRT-4's intercooler, and that thing compared to the MSP's cereal box also plays a big part in detonation prevention...Someone also said that Octane numbers describe the amount gasoline can be compressed before it ignites on its own...Not exactly..The numbers simply represent the concentration of actual unbroken octane chains in the gas per volume...Octane itself does not exactly lower a flash point of gasoline, which is what would be needed for it to be compressed more before igniting...But it does help prevent unwanted combustion (through excess heat) by making the ignition properties of the said gas more stable...meaning the heat associated with squeezing the mixture tighter are less likely to make it burst without a spark output from the plug...So in the end you are right...Just tried to clarify it a little if anyone was interested...