Catch Can

In regards to the parts/sections the catch clean would clean. How accessible are they with basic hand tools. Could these sections be manually cleaned?
 
The US has been ULSD for about a decade. Our biggest problem is fuel contamination. Due to the loss of the Sulfur (which has some lubrication properties) they lost the "fudge" factor in Diesel getting contaminated with small amounts of gasoline. (In the US is common to use the same pipelines for both Diesel and Gasoline, they basically run one, then a bladder, and then switch over (and sometimes they don't use a bladder).

Anyhow, the havoc it's causing to the Bosch Based HPFP Diesels (the CP4.x) basically you get some bad diesel, and the pump fails so bad they have to replace the whole fuel systems... New Fuel Tanks, new Common Rail, new injectors, new in-tank fuel pumps, a week of labor... $8-12K in bills.

I currently own a 2012 VW Jetta TDI, and I'm looking into replacing it with a CX-5 (why I'm here). Been very unhappy with my Jetta... the engine has been good, but the rest of the car has been junk, and with the fear of getting a batch of "bad diesel" and it's "game over" looming over my head makes me want to look elsewhere.
 
The US has been ULSD for about a decade.

Due to lobbying by domestic oil companies our ULSD was delayed until 2006-2007 (Alaska until 2010). Sweden had ULSD available with sulfur levels 3-7 times lower than our current ULSD standard as early as 1992. Since 2003 they have had zero sulfur diesel available for use in urban environments where improving air quality is more important for public health.
 
I should see the stuff it filters out? LOL!

First, I'll point out that Corksport's test was done on a modified engine, not stock. The engine has a short ram air intake, larger diameter down pipe, larger diameter exhaust pipe, intercooler, boosted turbo pressures and who knows what else. So, yes, if you screw up the breathing characteristics of an engine enough you can get it to burn dirty, cause water condensation in the crankcase and generally foul everything up. The test vehicle is so loaded up with unrefined Corksport mods it's no wonder it doesn't burn cleanly. Besides, the test vehicle was a Mazdaspeed3 turbo - not exactly Skyactiv technology we're talking about here - apples to oranges comparison in all respects.

So, no, the advertising photo does not convince me that my CX-5 would run better with an oil catch can. In fact, it reminds me of the vacuum cleaner salesman that visited my house as a small child. He put a white piece of filter paper in his vacuum and went around our (very clean) house sucking on the couch cushions, carpets, etc. When he pulled out the (now black) filter paper my mother was horrified and purchased his (very expensive) vacuum on the spot. Of course, his vacuum didn't work any better than our existing vacuum, he just applied the vacuum to a smaller surface area. Who vacuums their entire home two square inches at a time? But it sure made for a nice sales commission for the salesman.

Burn dirty? And what do you know about Corksport? Its so sad how you talk down to people. Your post are riddled with it. I'm sure there's no point in sharing my experience with you because you've got it all figured out but i've got 3 jars of crap my catch can has filtered out. And so do others i know, with modified and stock vehicles. The EGR is what "fouls everything up" and a canister filter with a proper medium can aid in filtering this.

I only visit this forum every few weeks and every time i do, your prancing around with hands on your hips talking about how you know everything about everything. And everything in this post is an assumption of yours but you state it like its fact. Skyactiv or not it still has an egr and it still does the same thing. You could even have facts from someones personal or professional experience and you would still find a way to shoot them down.

So you go ahead and wave your finger at me and let me have it. I'm sure I'm not the only one who is annoyed my you.
 
I only visit this forum every few weeks and every time i do, your prancing around with hands on your hips talking about how you know everything about everything. And everything in this post is an assumption of yours but you state it like its fact. Skyactiv or not it still has an egr and it still does the same thing. You could even have facts from someones personal or professional experience and you would still find a way to shoot them down.

Well you're certainly entitled to your opinion but you should try not to become so angry when another person's opinion differs from what you believe.

You haven't presented a shred of evidence to convince me that a crude can stuck in-line is going to benefit anyone but the person who sells it.

I guess we'll have to wait until my engine gets all choked up, starts to lose efficiency and eventually leaves me stranded by the side of the road. I guess then I'll be wishing I had listened to your advice and the joke will be on me. I think it's already starting to happen at 9,800 miles - my last tank only got me 506 miles before I had to fill up. Must be some serious gunk (scientific term) coating my engine internals causing me to lose compression.

In the meantime, you can relax knowing that you spent good money to protect yourself from the same fate.
 
Hello All...

I used a catch can on my old CX7 (modified). The amount of oil it filtered out was so minimal, I eventually gave up emptying it.

In two years, I'd say it filtered out maybe 5-10ml of oil. Hardly worth the time I spent fitting it.
 
Well you're certainly entitled to your opinion but you should try not to become so angry when another person's opinion differs from what you believe.

You haven't presented a shred of evidence to convince me that a crude can stuck in-line is going to benefit anyone but the person who sells it.

I guess we'll have to wait until my engine gets all choked up, starts to lose efficiency and eventually leaves me stranded by the side of the road. I guess then I'll be wishing I had listened to your advice and the joke will be on me. I think it's already starting to happen at 9,800 miles - my last tank only got me 506 miles before I had to fill up. Must be some serious gunk (scientific term) coating my engine internals causing me to lose compression.

In the meantime, you can relax knowing that you spent good money to protect yourself from the same fate.

I'm relaxed Mikey. Your must be reading it wrong. I just don't think your aware of how you come off in a lot of your post. That's all. What I've given to this thread is based on my personal experience, yours is an opinion. Is it not?
 
Back