I recently sold my MSP. Had it listed on autotrader & bargain news. Paid $95 combined for 0 calls.
A friend then told me how he sold his POS Accord (thing had like 300k miles on it) for far more than I ever thought anyone would pay... on craigslist. I created an ad (for free) and the next day I had at least a dozen calls. Within a week the car was sold. I feel I was pretty aggressive with my price (car had 115k miles but a few more mods than the OP's car) so that didn't hurt. In the end, I sold it for $6500 Considering you have less mileage and a far more marketable color (mine was orange) I think your $8500 asking price is fair. If you haven't already done so... put it up on craigslist. I think you'll be amazed at how much interest it generates.
A friend then told me how he sold his POS Accord (thing had like 300k miles on it) for far more than I ever thought anyone would pay... on craigslist. I created an ad (for free) and the next day I had at least a dozen calls. Within a week the car was sold. I feel I was pretty aggressive with my price (car had 115k miles but a few more mods than the OP's car) so that didn't hurt. In the end, I sold it for $6500 Considering you have less mileage and a far more marketable color (mine was orange) I think your $8500 asking price is fair. If you haven't already done so... put it up on craigslist. I think you'll be amazed at how much interest it generates.