Usually I take anything Consumer Reports puts out with a massive helping of salt, but in this case I would go with a healthy sprinkling.
Mazda has been the most reliable for myself. I bought a used base model 2011 Mazda CX-7 this past May, 1 owner, had 152,000 kms and was always dealer serviced. It currently sits at 165,000 kms and the only thing I have had to replace was a bad O2 sensor. I have to do the brakes this month or next, but otherwise it has been a solid suv for my daily commute.
My wife hates it as it doesn’t feel like the CX5 and its wider width, along with the basic stereo.