Ok, so yesterday I tried the screw trick on Ashlee's P5. All she has is a K&N short ram intake and a Magnaflow exhaust. Her gas mileage did get worse after we turned the screw down. And I figured out what the deal was as far as why my car it worked,but not on her car.
On my car I have a header which deletes the pre cat, so...the lower O2 sensor reads too much emissions and richens the fuel out to compensate for it. This is where I turned the screw down and it leaned it out so that I can get better gas mileage. More or less, returning it back to stock settings but manually.
I don't want to say that I was wrong, because on my car I wasn't wrong. But on a stock 2.0L or one that doesnt have a header, yes it won't work on their car.
Chris