So, another $250 total later, I got the wheels back (picked them up last night on my way back from Iowa). He machined the lip down to a "matte" finish and they look phenomenal considering the previous condition. He said there's so much paint/powdercoating on these wheels. He was taking off paint/p.coating for quite a few turns.
I highly recommend this place. I would have paid easily $120+ each wheel and wouldn't have had the love this guy (Larry) put into them. Great place, this Mirror Look is (yippy) - if any of you have custom polishing or other metal working needs, hit this guy up.
Now, all I have to do is install the springs, dampers, sway bar, intake, header, midpipe, catback, things, stuff, boxes, wrenches, (blah)