Well, thanks to this thread I went and bought a Mach3 Turbo and some Gillette Mach3 Comfort shaving gel. Shaved the puss this morning and shockingly my face didn't look like hamburger when I was done - just a little bit of bleeding by my adams apple. My face feels smoother compared to using an electric but it doesn't 'look' like a closer shave -- still have a little bit of a shadow in the beard area.
Question for eveyrone -- how many shaves does your razor last? It seems like I'm lucky to get 2 shavings out of a razor cartridge before I have to toss it and use a new one. That sucks.