MSP Turkey: FACTS

SoniCraze

Member
:
2003.5 MSP
Ok well i spend most of yesterday with Rob from Pineapple Racing (pineappleracing.com) with chris from corksport stopping by to help with some ideas.

The first thing we tried was to put in a bigger opening before the bov. The idea was if this was the bov making the turkey this bigger area would allow more pressure to build up before it vented, hopefully with fewer, stronger vents.
This did nothing.

We then caped off the intake pipe and the intercooler pipe and ran the car without a bov at all. Same turkey.
So we know the BOV has NOTHING to do with the actual turkey sound. Our bov is almost 100% quiet.

What does this leave? most people say wastegate. When i brought this up he said there is no way that the turkey is a sound coming from the wastegate. If it was we would hear it in our exhaust. When we took the last peace off the Ingen CAI we could hear the turkey coming from down the pipe, the turbo.

He then concluded that the turkey was this:
When your forcing air into the block everything is fine, when you release the throttle it causes the engine to close the intake not allowing air in. What then happens is the air that was between the turbo and the block is stuck. It builds up against the turbo then causes the turbo to actually spin to release the pressure, once it does this another build up, then so on then so on. Thats why there is a flutter.

He had some ideas on how to remedy this. First thing he noticed was that the line coming off the intercooler pipe to the bov was very small. He had a thought that if you made another hole, then another on the intake, and ran 2 stock bov it might actually help.

Another idea chris from corksport had was to use a twin chamber bov that would release any excess pressure but would stilll hold some in.

I was kind of wondering why mazda recalculated instead of vented. Rob had a fast answer and actually really liked that it did this. He explained than when you vent you loose all the pressure you built up. With it recalculating it then throws that pressurized air right back into the intake causing for a faster response between shifts.


I might have missed something but i tried to remember everything.

comments?
 
MAF, thats why it is recirculated. :D if not, you would stall. The MAF accounts for ALL air taken in, if you vent to atmosphere, the PCM is adding the fuel for the air, but the air is not there, causing a flooding condition.

Thats why most with aftermarket BOV's venting, are stalling.
 
There's absolutely no mystery as to why an ineffective BOV would cause the turkey noise. It's compressor surge or stall, as explained to you. The solution is not to remove the BOV but to make it work as well as possible. It has to open easily enough to vent all the air. It has to be able to vent enough pressure to prevent the stall. It has to be tight enough not to leak under boost, and NO tighter.

So, check to make sure the piston in the BOV moves freely. Make sure it's got a good signal line - Chris already noticed this one. If you've raised the boost, you may need to upgrade to another BOV that will allow you to dump more air.

There are no real secrets to the MSP turbo system. It's all fairly straightforward.

Keith
 
the sound isnt comming from the bov. We removed it and still same sound. I wasnt trying to make the sound go away i just wanted to know why it was there. People have put on aftermarket bov's on there msp's and it doesnt seem to do much to the turkey.
 
Removing the BOV won't solve the noise if it is in fact compressor stall. That's exactly the sort of thing the BOV is designed to PREVENT. The problem is not that the BOV is making noise, but that it's not working well enough to prevent the stall.

Keith
 
SoniCraze said:
the sound isnt comming from the bov. We removed it and still same sound. I wasnt trying to make the sound go away i just wanted to know why it was there. People have put on aftermarket bov's on there msp's and it doesnt seem to do much to the turkey.

Keith@FP said:
Removing the BOV won't solve the noise if it is in fact compressor stall. That's exactly the sort of thing the BOV is designed to PREVENT. The problem is not that the BOV is making noise, but that it's not working well enough to prevent the stall.

Keith


Looks like we have an agreement.;)

-Sp
 
I was hoping that somehow this was not going to be the case, but it is more than obvious now. Next week, I have some time to go back home and work on the car, so I will talk to my buddy at the machine shop and the welder across the street about getting a short, 1" nipple welded onto the injen in place of the tiny return tube that is there now. I will try running a 1"ID hose from the BOV to the new nipple. I will also try giving the valve a better vaccum source as mentioned by Robert in one of the other threads about this. I guess if that does not work, then I will have an HKS SSQV for sale:)
 
Last edited:
Was the sound any louder or different at all when you took out the BPV??? It worries me a lot to think that there was no difference in sound between the stock BPV, and not having one at all.
 
i didnt run it very much, just once thru 1st to 2nd and once i heard it i turned around and came back. It didnt seem any less loud.

Also look into the line comming off the plastic pipe, that intercooler line is really really small there to. So even if you have a fat line goin back to the intake your still restricted there...right?
 
I'll second that, if you look in the forced induction forum, "msp, gobble" I pretty much have been saying the same thing.


StreetPreacher said:
Looks like we have an agreement.;)

-Sp
 
I thought this wasnt a mistery. That turkey sound is the turbo. You can hear it in the intake before the compressor and if you have a straight exhaust pipe, you can hear the poping noise in the exhaust when the surge comes.

The BPV used in the mazdaspeed is not efficient and is causing compressor surge, thats all.
 
SoniCraze said:
i didnt run it very much, just once thru 1st to 2nd and once i heard it i turned around and came back. It didnt seem any less loud.

It's not less gobble that we want, I was hoping that it was way louder than normal. If there was no difference in sound at all, then the stock BPV+injen intake causes just as much compressor surge than no valve at all. Not good.



SoniCraze said:
Also look into the line comming off the plastic pipe, that intercooler line is really really small there to. So even if you have a fat line goin back to the intake your still restricted there...right?

I do not have that line anymore, but yeah, all msp's with stock IC plumbing are restricted by that spot just as much as the return on the injen.

I am starting to think that the stock airbox maybe wasn't muffling all that sound, maybe the injen just causes that much more compressor surge. But then again, why does someone who has no tiny little return line to deal with because they are running open vent still have the turkey? Yet others claim to have eliminated it by just changing to hardpipes and BOV. WTF?!?!?!?! my head hurts now.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, in that vid it was set to the softest setting it could without the screw coming out:)

Do you have any idea why mazda put the wastegate and BPV on the same vaccum source? Still makes no sense to me.
 

New Threads and Articles

Back