I don't understand (dunno) . Current GM and current VW are about the same reliability wise. Although GM doesn't have stupid engineering eccentricities such as having bolts instead of studs to hold the wheel and a stupid and hard to use spark plug tool that my friend's GTI VR6 has. Not to mention now it's running only on 5 cylinders and it's not like he beats it. If anything he babies it which is why he swore of VW's forever. Maybe it's a lemon but I don't really think so because it was fine for 80 k miles.
However for the MSP vs. Spec V, the MSP is much more desirable but of course more expensive. The MSP imo looks better inside and out, handles better, shifts better, has exclusivety (sp?), and I love turbo motors. The spec v i think isn't a bad car but I much rather have other cars than it.
<edit>I also rather have the 3 over the spec V because the spec v maybe faster but not by that much. The 3 also has a slick shifter, with pretty good handling to boot, looking the business, and look at that interior. Is this really a econo car cause it doesn't look suck.