GF and I are going on a break...

Thug541

Member
Contributor
:
2002 Mazda Protege ES
So yeah. let me tell the story. I am not really expecting like "sorry" replies or advice, i'm move just writing my thoughts down to help me deal:

So, me and my girlfriend have beengoing out for a lil over 8 months now. We got together when I was a senior in college and she was a sophmore. We had an AMAZING relationship. We more or less lived with each other for 7 months. In the summer, I was taking classes to finish up completly and she stayed in my room the whole summer basically. We never got tired of each other or anything and every aspect of the relationship was to me, perfect.

Now, I moved back home (about 160 miles away) beginning of september. My gf is a very needy/affectionate person. One reason I didnt' want to even get into the relationship was I was afraid what would happen when I graduated. She reassured me we would do great. However, as time passed, she would miss me to an extreme degree. When i would go up and visit it was great, but when I left, she would cry right before I go. In early october, right after one of my visits she said we needed to talk. She was explaining how she was not happy. She basically could not deal with the distance. She was feeling very misersable and was doubting if we could last. (remember, she has 2 more years of college and she is going to grad school.) I reassured her I was in this for the long haul and that I would not be giving up on her. I said I would try better to call everyday just to talk (i have weird habits with the phone where i hate it haha.) We left off as still together and we did indeed talk a lot.

I started getting concnered however as when I would attempt to visit she found reasons why I shouldn't come up such as, she was working all weekend (which she does) and had to study for 2 tests. She also lost her wallet one weekend and didn't want me to come up cause we couldn't go out because she didn't have an ID. Of course I said I would easily come out just to go to the movies and spend time. So I was supposed to come up this weekend. However, she said we needed to talk again and this time she came right out and said she thinks we need to go on a break. She restated she was not happy and she needed time to herself to figure out what she wants. I brought up how I dont' want to go on a break, how are relationship is AMAZING when we are together. She agreed but said...the problem is we are not together. She said the reason she didn't want me to come up was because she was debating if we needed to go on a break. I personally think she knows how hard it would be to say "lets go on a break" after being together again and/or she didn't want to feel the hurt of me leaving again.

But it basically is we are on a break now. I left it as we can see other people , you know, to see if our relationship is what she wants, but we can't hook up or do anything with them. I am just hurt that at the first sign of a monkey wrench into the relationship she seems to be giving up. Granted, she was in a long distance relationship when she got to college and it ended terribly, so I feel she is comparing the situation again....which is giving me a very unfair advantage. I even suggested I move back up to the college are (Albany, NY) and find a job there because even I wasn't happy (or at least MUCH happier with her). However shes afraid of the pressure that would put on her. She said what if we broke up and you moved up here for me...I would feel terrible. So now we are on a break. She needs time to herself, and I have to respect that. She is young and a junior in college and shes right...she shouldn't have to feel terrible.

The thing I don't understand is if we were to end it and she truly is still in Love with me she would still be miserable. Ending a relationship that rocks when you are together would leave you missing it just as much as us not being together while we are a couple. I just don't want to be strung along on this break only to break up a month later becuase I have no intention of seeing anyone else or anything like that....but if she knows she wants to break up now and doesn't want to fully commit to that, I would be very upset.

Basically this sucks and is at a terrible time. I am having trouble finding a job post college, my father is selling the house in a month time so I have to find some where to live and my cat died 3 weeks ago (thats just kicking a man while hes down.) I am actually a bit peeved she would do this to me while I am having a rough time in life, but at the same time, I respect her for being honest with me about the situation. Anywho....Love sucks. It makes you miserable. I am willing to wait for her tho. Even if we fully broke up. College is a rough time on relationships and shes still young. We'll see how things go.
 
The relationship is young to begin with.....dont expect too much outta this break man. Like u said, since it happened to her once.....shes not afraid for it to happen again. Id say go do what u gotta do, and see whats out there.....shes already doing it.

Best of luck to you both.

My .02
 
i have friends who are/were in a long distance relationship and they never work out.. just find a new girl, it's hard but you'll get over it.
 
Thug541 said:
The thing I don't understand is if we were to end it and she truly is still in Love with me she would still be miserable. Ending a relationship that rocks when you are together would leave you missing it just as much as us not being together while we are a couple.
Exactly. I don't want to sound mean about it but this is why a break is never good - I don't even know why we call it "a break". It should be called "I want to have sex with someone else, but stay here just in case that doesn't turn out." That is reality because like you said above, if she's miserable because she doesn't get to see you enough, how on Earth does seeing and hearing from you even less makes things less miserable? I don't know - I just don't like shady people like that that don't lay it all out like it truly is. Just my opinion.
 
hey man i have a different view from the ones posted above.
At this point it seems you really have nothing to lose. You are not committed to where you are right now; you wont have a roof over your head and you dont a have a job yet. You definteily like this girl and are willing to work for the relationship. If she feels the way you described it then she seems like a good girl and you sound like you are very happy with her. I think you should try moving to that area and see what happens. I dont see a downside to it from my point of view. You will spend time with her; you know the areas as you went to college there for 4 years. You may find a job you like and maybe you can find a place together or whatever.
Say worst case scenario, she was lying to you she just wanted to see other people and you guys break it off. Well, you will be in the same position you are right now except that hopefully you now have a job. Also then at least you would be 100% free and not in this relationship limbo that sucks.
Believe staying in this limbo will make you very bitter if this doesnt work out. You will feel she lied to you and took advantage of you. Giving it a try is not showing weakness or being whipped; it is trying for something you truely want.
I know you didnt want advice but i couldnt help myself.
Good luck with everything...
 
Thanks everyone. This first day sucks...I just want to call her and see whats up, and i'm trying really hard just to give her her space right now. I really don't think shes lying to me. She has been completly honest to me in the past so I don't think she would start lying now. She was questioning though if her heart is in it as much as it used to be....which a big reason I think is the fact shes in college for 2 more years. Blah....hopefully it goes well.
 
i could be WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY off here, but from my past experiences, if A. they don't want you coming by and B. make up excuses...and C. finally break it off, there's another guy. but that's just what i've learned...hopefully, that's not the case, but after reading your post, that what i think happened. just move on...if it's meant to be it'll work out...if not, you only have 8 months invested and you know what a good relationship is all about.
 
may be just me, but i would never get back together with a girl i have been with if she slept with another guy

i feel if you are together for a certain time then you are together forever, if you need another guy after me i don't want you back

i say if she needs the break to think about things then fine, if she thinks about things in the bed of another guy let her go
 
yeah, 'go on break' usually means it's over. don't be that 'fallback guy', it's suffocating and totally sucks, just move on
 
I understand your concerns....and believe me, I really thought there was another guy. You know, someone who lives around her. She tells me about this guy who she works with who once tried to hook up with her, and she kicked him and ran away, but she tells me these things, when someone ever tries anything. He ended up apologizing and they are becoming close friends...as in he takes her to work, or they may hang out together. However, all the trust i built up with her won't let me believe she would lie to me. I asked her the first time we talked if she was liking another guy and she said no. So I am going to believe her for now.
 
Thug541 said:
He ended up apologizing and they are becoming close friends...as in he takes her to work, or they may hang out together.

they may not be seeing each other now...but they're a little more than close friends. you may not believe me or anyone else...but it's right there in front of you. i'm not saying anything to be an ass...i'm just speaking from being in your situation more than once...and it has always ended up the same way.
 
^agrees w/ topher, looks like that dude is working his mojo quite nicely, she's at least nice enough to 'take a break' with you first before getting w/ him...
 
yep, the bait and switch method

come off as a jerk first, then do a 180 and tell her you are sorry and she is better than other girl that he has done that with, then slowly work the mojo proving you repect her, her feeling and things she cares about

been there, done that:)

i'm not saying give up on it, i am just saying be defensive from now on until you are living together again
 
Last edited:
Yeah I warned her about these things before. Like when the kid was getting her a job, I warned her, hes playing the friend role, watch he will try something. And he did, and she said I was right. But now hes settling back into the good guy role...prob. even telling her things like....if you are not happy with the distance, take a break etc. etc. I just wrote her a lengthy email expressing all my concerns and where i am feeling on the situation right now. I brought up this guy not as an attack but as a concern about him, or any other guy who is up there around you more than me can make you questions if we should be together. I said, if you are sincierly wanting a break to figure out if the pain you are going through right now with the distance is worth it in 2 years when we can be together....i will wait. But if its becuase you may be finding interest in guys in a more similar situation as yourself....then maybe a break is pointless, beucase we know how that will prob. end up.
 
Last edited:
ZoomVT said:
I think you should try moving to that area and see what happens. I dont see a downside to it from my point of view. You will spend time with her; you know the areas as you went to college there for 4 years. You may find a job you like and maybe you can find a place together or whatever.

So, image you just got fired, would you: A. Set-up a hot dog stand and sell dogs every day in the hopes that you old boss will see how good a worker you were and hire you back? Or, B. Get wasted, cry a little, wake up the next day and put an add in the paper selling your self as an escort...show the f*cking pimp you can do it on your own!?!?

Dude, you have [probably] lived like 1% of the possible good life that you have in front of you right now. You have a college degree and your health; make something of your self. Move to a new city, where no one knows you and you know no one. Remake yourself into the man you want to be. Chicks will flock to the confidence, indipendance, and money that you'll have no that you are really on your own, with a real job, in a real city.

What ever you do...DO NOT MOVE BACK TO YOUR OLD COLLEGE TOWN!
 
she is definitely seeing someone else. i would try to get over her and move on. plenty of other girls out there
 
well after reading about the other dude then i think you should move on. I guess i was assuming different circumstances.

Dude, you have [probably] lived like 1% of the possible good life that you have in front of you right now. You have a college degree and your health; make something of your self. Move to a new city, where no one knows you and you know no one. Remake yourself into the man you want to be. Chicks will flock to the confidence, indipendance, and money that you'll have no that you are really on your own, with a real job, in a real city.

i actually agree with you here, it is fair to point out that it is not for everyone. SOme people are not cut out to do that kind of decision. And if you are not, then it will suck. If you are capable o starting from scratch then most definitely do it. It is very rewarding.
 
Okay, here comes my female perspective, AND with having quite a lot of personal experience with long-distance relationships.

First off, guys -- don't assume that younger females are incapable of being faithful during long-distance relationships. I dated a guy for two years starting when I was 20, and when he was sent overseas for ten months (during which we RARELY spoke), I was NEVER unfaithful. I've always had my guy friends (that's just my personality, seeing as I'm a tomboy), but even the 'younger' girls are capable of being true to a guy when he's away -- IF they really love them.

However. The fact that your girl is asking for a 'break' is indeed a bad sign. At the very least, it's clear proof that she's unhappy. However, what makes me distinctly suspicious is that she made excuses for you to not come up some weekends. THAT strikes me as fishy. Do you have any mutual friends that you could trust enough to ask about her habits? As in, do you have a buddy that would be able to see if she's already gotten involved with another guy, or would know if she HAS been seeing someone else? That would be VERY helpful.

I've known long-distance relationships that work out -- BUT there's a catch, IMO. The couple cannot be 'younger'. I haven't seen them work, really, in people under 22. I guess the maturity level (in general) isn't there yet to be able to have the trust and compromise needed to nuture the relationship's survival.

Currently, I'm in a semi-long distance relationship. Brandon lives about an hour away. However, we ALWAYS make time to see each other AT LEAST every other weekend, if not more often. And we make sure to make the time we're together memorable. We'll do stuff -- we've gone whitewater rafting, to different beach locations, to the mountains, camping, and so on. That's another factor you need to have to make a long-distance relationship work: QUALITY time. We also have plans for our future, which serves to be very reassuring and makes our bond stronger. And we speak on the phone CONSTANTLY -- at least once a day, though most days it's even more. It's a lot of things .. but, like I said, a lot of things that I don't believe 'younger' people are ready for or capable of dealing with.

So while long-distance relationships are definitely difficult, they're not impossible. You just have to be mature enough and confident enough both in yourself and the other person -- there has to be a lot of love, a lot of trust, and a lot of faith.

You need to ask yourself not only if YOU want to put the effort into making your relationship work, but if you think SHE wants to. It's a two-way street. You can't put enough into it for both of you -- it's not supposed to work that way. Her saying that she wants a break is basically her way of saying she's giving up. You can beg and plead and bargain -- but in the end, TRUST ME, it will only make things more hurtful in the end.

I suggest you take this opportunity that she's presented to you. She wants a break? Fine. Then YOU take a break, too. Go out with other girls in your area. Take time to yourself. See what it's like to be single again and have a bajillion options open to you. You might surprise yourself.

Okay, I'll shut up now.
 
Rush said:
Currently, I'm in a semi-long distance relationship. Brandon lives about an hour away. However, we ALWAYS make time to see each other AT LEAST every other weekend, if not more often.

Rush, let me be the first to say that we [guys] appreciate your persepctive. But I gotta call you out on your long-distance relationship strategy. I work about 45 minutes from my house. My wife commutes a little over an hour. We live together in the middle (and we did the same before we were married). Living an hour a part and seeing each other 2 days out of every 14 does not describe the kind of close, meaningful relationship that Thugs had or wants. In fact, I think he is leaving the very same kind of convenice-based relationship I dare say you have.

Thugs, the first 5 years after college will define you. College gives you [life] experience that will guide the decisions you make in your twenties that will forever color your life. Make those decisions the best they can be for your future, not your past. Carpe diem! Carpe...tomorrow, too. At the very least Thugs, listen to Rush's last para, she speak the truth.
 
Back