Best cars for grads? Think of what grandma might drive

:
2006 Mazda Speed6
toyotax-wide-community.jpg

Ah, high-school graduation time. Parents, you're one step closer to dropping your kid off on the steps of a college campus or watching them head out for their first job. What better way to reward them for their sheepskin than with a their first (used) car.

But wait. They're young, impetuous -- and they are more likely to crash. To protect them, your biggest investment, the Wall Street Journal's Joe White wrote a l-o-n-g article advocating that you buy them a car that only a grandma could love -- practical, safe, cheap and above all, completely boring. If they didn't hate you enough already for grounding them for pitching M&Ms into the lamp shade, give them a car that will extend that dislike at least another generation.

White reasons that there is a nexus between Insurance Institute ratings for safety and Consumer Reports ratings for reliability. So to save you having to slog through his long explanation, here are his recommendations for recent vintage yawn-mobiles:

2004-2006 Toyota Camry

2005-2007 Honda Accord

2008-2009 Chevrolet Malibu

2008-2009 Ford Fusion

2006-2009 Subaru Legacy

2008 Ford Taurus

2003 Lexus ES

2006 Audi A4

White, we suspect, figures it's better kids be bored than dead. Can't argue with that.

------------------

I don't think the A4 and the Legacy belong to that list, they are probably not the fastest car but I dont think they are grandma's car.
 
A subaru legacy isn't terribly boring.

I'd also recommend against the a4. a recent grad isn't going to have the money to maintain that thing.
 
legacy is quite nice in it's GT form, but otherwise it is boring

The a4, heck I'll take one

I'm a little puzzled why it's only the 2005-2007 accord though?!? since the model ran from 03-07. Imho, the ugliest model accord ever. Even still, a v6 sedan with 6 speed ran 0-60 in 5.9 sec - not bad for "boring".
 
Cars i owned between 18-22

1995 Ford Probe GT (turbo'd)
2000 Mercury Cougar v6 (turbo'd)
2003.5 Mazda Protege5 (never got around to anything other than IHE & suspension LOL)
 
Cars i owned between 18-22

1995 Ford Probe GT (turbo'd)
2000 Mercury Cougar v6 (turbo'd)
2003.5 Mazda Protege5 (never got around to anything other than IHE & suspension LOL)
In stock form, none of those are anything special. Just because a car is good for a particular age doesn't mean they're going to leave it alone (i.e. Civics). Sorry, I'm a strong believer kids shouldn't have (i.e. be given) "fast" cars.

Cars I owned between 18-22:
1986 Toyota Pickup
2002 Mazda Protege (turbo'd, and then some...)
 
Cars i owned between 18-22

1995 Ford Probe GT (turbo'd)
2000 Mercury Cougar v6 (turbo'd)
2003.5 Mazda Protege5 (never got around to anything other than IHE & suspension LOL)

My 18-22 years of age:

1989 300zx
1990 Rx-7 gtu-s
2001 Mazda protege MP3 ;)
 
Last edited:
all im saying with mine are they're more young inspired cars...I'm sorry but i'm seeing upper 20s and on with that entire list
 
age 16- early 20's

1990 - Prelude s 5speed
1992 bought in 94 - Prelude SR - 5speed
1997- Prelude Sr
1999 - V6 Accord coupe, handa factory ground effects wheels etc

I'm still alive, and outside of one jackass jumping a stop sign and damn near killing me, no accidents on my behalf.

Stereotyping is not a good thing for anyone to do. Just because you are young, doesn't mean you are stupid and a bad driver. I'd rather get the 75 yr olds off the roads.
 
My lineup isn't too impressive.

16: 87 buick century wagon
16-19: 97 grand am
19-22: 04 mazda 6i hatch
22: 97 Tacoma 4x4
22 to present: 96 miata, 04 forester
 
Age16-current (25)

1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee
2000 Jeep Grand Cherokee
2005 Mazda6S Hatchback

those jeeps were tanks and could haul a bunch of stuff, but I am never going back to SUV's....unless it's a tow vehicle for a track toy :D
 
Back