Are these Vapor canister purge valves the same..?

[leandoer]

Reliability of parts is one thing but are these to Vapor Canister Purge Valve the same.

https://www.amazon.com (commissions earned)

RockAuto ( $43.00 )

 

[theblooms]

When it comes to solenoids and sensors, I recommend ONLY using OEM parts.

Pardon Our Interruption...

 

[leandoer]

When it comes to solenoids and sensors, I recommend ONLY using OEM parts.

Pardon Our Interruption...

Yeah. I was thinking the same thing.
Also the Amazon one picture and arrived product are different. The arrived product male house tips diameters are smaller than the OEM vapor canister diameters.

 

[theblooms]

I have to ask this, too: is your solenoid actually bad? Blow through it with your mouth, see if it passes air. Now apply 12v and blow through it again.
Is it wide open one way, and *completely* sealed the other? If so, the solenoid is good, and doesn't need to be replaced. Your leak will be somewhere else.

 

[leandoer]

I have to ask this, too: is your solenoid actually bad? Blow through it with your mouth, see if it passes air. Now apply 12v and blow through it again.
Is it wide open one way, and *completely* sealed the other? If so, the solenoid is good, and doesn't need to be replaced. Your leak will be somewhere else.

Good qustion. Never put current through it to check. Did clean it out and have been hearing clicking and I dont think its coming from the valve train so I was thinking it was the Purge Valve.
Thanks for that tip tho, deff will try and get back.