Update After Second Garage
Just got car back from the second garage - dealership. This makes the third attempt in all (2 at the first place - horrible work, 1 at the second) Paint match is pretty darn spot on, especially with the hood. The painted side is a tad shinier than the rest of the vehicle but I was told it will even out in time, especially after a good cleaning and waxing of the whole vehicle. There's very, very minor paint run/buildup along door edges which is actually consistent with factory painted side. They did also have to clean up overspray on the inside of the vehicle as well as the outside from the clearcoat job done at the last place. In addition they removed the appropriate mils of paint layer on the previous botch job so that it is more consistent with the rest of the vehicle. Pretty satisfied with the paint job.
Only a few issues, though. Front door tint is scratched and that was actually pointed out to me by the shop manager. He said they will pay to have the window retinted. Also, I noticed that the clear gauge cluster shield has some deep scratches in it that must have occurred during the interior cleanup from the overspray. So, they are also going to replace that shield too after finding out if it is a one piece or three piece unit. Finally, I think they need to make the doors just a tad tigher, as there's just a bit too much play in them.
Otherwise, I am almost back to original condition, pre accident.