When I bought the 14 CX-5 back in 13 out the door price in the low $20s it was what I expected for a cheap econo CUV. It has served me well through the years and I expect for a couple more at least. I have to admit that my current judgment and skepticism of the CX-5 is based on my model and year. I have progressed well financially and can definitely step up a class so my current top picks are the next level up to have a certain blend of quietness and performance.
My CX-5 has a lot of road noise (IMO) at highway speed. Sure I haven't used a sound meter, but based on coming off the interstate on a long drive is becomes apparent when slowing down how loud I had the music volume just to hear the lyrics or dialog from sports or whatever. Also having to speak a touch louder to my wife so we can hear each other. I am not saying we are screaming at each other, but it take a little more effort. I suppose my judgment of the current models could be unfair. I do have enough experience with mine in comparison to riding with friends that own Lexus, MB, Porsche and others in that class that there is a significant difference in terms of interior sound. Volume of music and effort to talk is greatly reduced. That is not scientific by any means, but it is a reality. My CX-5 is better on the interstate than my previous Nissan Titan with performance exhaust. Wow! that got old really fast with droning for a 5 to 6 hour drive. Loved how it towed my boat, but the exhaust noise was wearisome even in local traffic. Sold the truck as soon as I sold the boat.
Talking to a coworker that is now a Lexus fan said she was amazed on how less stressed she felt after a 6 hour drive than she did when they were buying from the economy class of cars. She said she could never step down after having that level of comfort and quietness on the interstate. I guess now that I am in my 50's I want to get that same experience, but also hope to have a touch more performance as well. If Mazda is truly becoming premium than I will at least give a test drive. I am interested to see observations from those of you that get the 19 CX-5.