So Amanda and I went and drove a few Miatas last weekend. A '92 with 170k and an '07 with 40k. Amanda wasn't very fond of the NA and it had some issues. I would've never bought the one we drove but i wanted her to get a feel for a cheap car. Obviously she liked the 07 more and i actually didn't have trouble driving it. Actually she REALLY liked the 07. At this point though, i think we may just hold off on the 'toy car' idea until next spring when my MS6 is paid off. Then we could swing another car payment and the MS6 will become my winter car and we'll share a new-ish miata. Insurance says it'll cost $200/6months for it to be a part-time car with max of 8,000 miles. If we only drive it half the year and on nice days that should be about the mileage we'd put on it.
I still like the idea of an old MR2 beater though. I just haven't found one for sale nearby. The closest ones are in Providence and I'm just not up for a drive down there right now. I think the key point is price. I could pay cash for something under $2k right now...or we could finance something in a year.
BTW, Oleg practically stole that Scuubie. If I could find a deal like that on a fun car for the summer i'd be all over it. i'm just not sure the NA miata is the route i'd want to take though.