Put them on because I dont like the other ones I had and because I wanted to see how it looked. Yes the tires are too small...I plan on getting either 235/35 or 225/40...I need more sidewall...I loved these rims on my Old 5 but not sure I'm a fan of them on here, looking at ordering a rim from Tire Rack that I liked and seeing how it looks before selling these off. About 19's being too Big.... Really? Those wheel wells are huge....those 19's look like 17's on there....but everyones entitle to there opinion...I'm cool with that