I thought a lot about this and made this pro and cons table. In all cases,
looks is subjective and personal, this is from my research and observations to date.
The level of protection is a risk to take in terms of rock chips causing paint damage (that could be further mitigated using a paint protection film). If it is just dirt then it is a matter of time (or $) to clean the vehicle.
Option | Pros | Cons | Added Protection |
No splash / mud guards |
- No spending $ or time to buy and install
| | None |
Mazda OEM Splash Guards (Front: 0000-8H-R10, Rear: KD33-V3-460) |
- OEM
- May be more solid due to shape (not just flaps)
- Some added protection from splashing dirt / debris from own wheels into rockers
|
- Generally smaller than aftermarket ones and less added protection
- Front splash guards are much smaller and offers little added protection
- Generally more costly than aftermarket ones
| Some |
Aftermarket Mud Flaps (like Rokblokz or Rally Armor or unbranded) |
- More added protection from splashing dirt / debris from own wheels into rockers
- Generally less costly
- More customizable (choices)
|
- In snowy areas, larger mud flaps may get caught in snow (e.g.: backing off), one anecdotal report of ripping off the attached part...
- In very cold areas, they may crack or break
- Fit may vary
| More |
Comments welcomed!