well hers isnt the S, but the motor is really about the same in the city, you know the difference when you are on the onramp as the high end of the 2.3 is so much better but around town, the 3i is quiter, the 16" wheels are alot softer and i wish my S had 16s instead of the 17s as mine jar the hell out of me on these horid toledo roads. As for hatch vs sedan, I feel cooler in the sedan, as hatches are only cool to people that like hatches or owned one, the hatch carries more goods, i like it better. For example i went to sears and bought a huge treadmill, i scooted up my seat, put the back seats down, and got this HUGE box in my car (barely), I would never have been able to do that in the 4 door. In a wierd way, the 5 door is my truck.