I totally agree with you about the noise going away as the engine warms up. Also about the high silicone ones. We use the SRPs which are high in silicon to get rid of the idle noise.
However, I disagree about the piston loosing its integrity when machined down. We have run cars with machined pistons up to 22 psi without any trouble. In fact, we only use forged ones when we run turbo and Nitrous together.
The pistons are machined in a CNC to get the same compression on all 4 of them.
The stock piston will take a lot of power if the engine is well tuned.
If you get a lean mixture or detonation due to a very advance timing, not even the best forged piston will take it.
The majority of all the 2001 + FS motors with blown engines have had problems number 1- pistons cracking number 2- rods bending and eventually snapping. The pistons i'll agree can take some abuse but not extended periods of detonation. I find that it isnt worth the time to machine nor wait for it to be machined. The pistons that come from JE/ SRP are already balanced and can handle much more than the stock pistons can. They have a tendency to crack literally around valve relief. If it is cost effective for you then good luck but the motor we did it to could NOT hanlde those cylinder pressures and temps. The aftermarket units that have a silicon content above eutectic standards also act as a barrier to heat and protect the piston at higher rpms. It is my opinion that ht eforged aluminum is the way to go
Juan