HELP! Oil change fiasco

bonesmp5 said:
might just be me -- but the word *oil* seemed to be used for both the engine and tranny. please dont put oil in the tranny -- hehehehe

I couldn't sleep all night. I'm about to take my gf to work in her car and than come back home to fix this mess. I'm hoping that both engine and trany are ok. They should be. Thanks for everyone's help!

I know this seems funny, and what gets me is that I used to work in a shop when I was a teenager. I've changed oil hundreds of times... Gee, I remember wondering "That oil smells weird"

I'll get new tranny fluid and I'll drain the 8 qt of oil in my engine (**** I still can't believe I did that) put new oil in and hopefully everything will be alright.
 
Guinnessman said:
You mean the tube that I check the level with right? Can I put back the oil I drained accidently?

yes, that tube, and NO, do not put that oil back in

it's been contaminated now - toss it out
 
lol. alright guys just take it easy on the guy. he made a mistake.
a lot of people make mistakes at stuff they should know. lkets try to help him get his car on the road without a broken transmission.
 
ZoomVT said:
lol. alright guys just take it easy on the guy. he made a mistake.
a lot of people make mistakes at stuff they should know. lkets try to help him get his car on the road without a broken transmission.

Alright guys, everything is now ok. s***, I still can not believe I've done this. After I found the correct drain plug I was scratching my head - I still wonder how many people have actually done this. Anyways, the trans seems perfectly fine, it actually shifts smoother than before :-)

The engine is fine too, it's got a brand new Castrol full syntetic oil.

The only complaint that I have about this mazda of mine is that the dip stick for trans fluid is diffcult to read. I accidently drained about 4 qts of fluid and I put back 4qts of multi vehicle ATF that suppose to work with my car. I figure the levels should be ok, but I'll wait until the trany cools down and check it again.

Here's the + and -

+ I learned very well where proper drain plugs are
+ I learned how to partially replace trany fluid
+ I learned that trany has fluid not oil

- Lost about 7 years of my life due to stress
- developed stomach alcer
- spent more money that I would at a full service oil change station

That's that... Thanks everyone!
 
Hard school - but good lessons.

Ease up on the stress. Take the wife/gf out tonite and kick back. (either, not both :))

Live long and prosper.
 
This is false...Transmission fluid is a high weight gear oil, so by calling it oil, he is correct :)
G-Papi said:
I'm also concerned that you keep referring to transmission fluid as oil. It is not oil ~ it's transmission fluid!! Know the difference.
 
evilmonkeyMSP said:
This is false...Transmission fluid is a high weight gear oil, so by calling it oil, he is correct :)

Why you wanna go and confuse the guy.

OK then, Motor oil, by definition is a fluid, so it's motor fluid, but so is coolant . . . um, . . . hummm. . .

(peep)
 
Ease up on the stress. Take the wife/gf out tonite and kick back. (either, not both :))

Thats very funny. you can do like in Goodfellas, one on friday and the other on saturdays.
 
wow, good to hear everything is okay. i think i would've took a dump in my pants after all that for overfilling my engine and draining my tranny
 
evilmonkeyMSP said:
This is false...Transmission fluid is a high weight gear oil, so by calling it oil, he is correct :)

Most ATF is actually a super-high detergent 20W oil. For this car, that might be considered heavy but it's really not. :D

But basically, if it's a combustible lubricant and it flows at room temp, it's an oil.

Any oil is also a fluid, as fluidity only implies that it's a liquid. It all just comes down to accepted terminology.
 
Last edited:
lol yeah I know...just letting him know it is oil tho...I know some comes in 75w so it was just a reference :p
goldwing2000 said:
Most ATF is actually a super-high detergent 20W oil. For this car, that might be considered heavy but it's really not. :D
 
Awl~riteee, then . .
Given that a fluid is a continuous substance that tends to take the shape of its container; either liquid or gas, let's see, now.

I was talking to a guy who had drained his transmission instead of his oil pan, and had put four quarts of oil in his motor on top of the dirty oil that was still in there. He wasn't sure about putting transmission fluid down the dipstick tube because it was so small (and probably inconveniently located for a direct pour). Top this off with him talking about putting oil back in the automatic transmission.

It is easy to start with what is known and move to the unknown. The case here led me to believe that what was known was the biggest unknown of all.

I subsequently found it safe to presume no knowledge at all, and simply point out the difference in motor oil and transmission fluid. Inasmuch as the shopper at Autozone, Walmart, or Advance will never find Automatic Transmission Oil labels on any container, I simply told him what to look for ~ ATF, Automatic Transmission Fluid., as it is labeled. I even told him to get the type appropriate to his vehicle as indicated either in the manual, or on the dipstick.

I just wanted him to know what he was looking for. I'd never tell anybody to look for hydraulic fluids for their brakes, or power steernig. They'd get laughed away from the counter.

I've had such fun writing this that I want to go on, but I'm laughing so hard right now at the absurdity of it all.

Go have a beer, er . . . lager . . . er malt . . . alcoholic beverage . . .

:):):):):)
 
evilmonkeyMSP said:
lol yeah I know...just letting him know it is oil tho...I know some comes in 75w so it was just a reference :p

Not for an automatic transmission, it doesn't.

G-Papi: and now you've discovered the reason for 98% of all internet forums. Arguing about pointless crap. (thumb)
 
Last edited:
Just remember, every day is a school day, and as we get older, most of that is refresher training. Glad to hear everything is back as it should be, and no damage was done.
 

New Threads and Articles

Back