I understand that they can go over every inch of the car, but what gives them the right to go through personal items such as paper in the console? Even if they had a reason to enter the console, nothing should let them take a personal piece of paper, look at it, look for his name, car, etc. Move it aside, yes. Read it, no. A car and everything in it is personal property.
OP: Go to another dealer or get a lawyer. Keep in mind if you do have to go to court, it will cost a LOT of money. lawyers are not cheep. I spent $1500 on one this year to draft and file a piece of paper, no court apperances at all. Also, as someone already mentioned, why do you have these tickets in your car, especially if it was from your 'younger days'? Only reason I see that you would keep them is to show off how 'bad ass' you are, which would mean that you haven't grown up and are still a danger to me and everyone else. But that's just my perception.
Pistonripper: at leest he kan spel. go tuhrn a rench, smag.