The boost pressures quoted from our website are based on information gathered primarily from the VW/Audi market. The valve that the VAG (Volkswagen Audi Group) 1.8T uses shares the same internals as the MAZ2.3 valve that we manufacture. However the vacuum characteristics of the 1.8T are VERY different from your engine and the VW valve is installed with boost entering what would be the discharge port on the FMDVMAZ3 so that information isn't really relevant.
My recommendation, which will change if new information presents itself:
Yellow, yellow with shim - Stock
Yellow with shim, blue - Mild upgrades with only a negligible increase in boost
Blue, blue with shims - Common bolt on parts with significant increase in boost
Blue with shims, Red - High boost applications
Spring pressure doesn't tell the entire story. You must also take into account the effected area of the piston or the diaphragm. Given the same amount of boost or vacuum there is more force acting on the OEM valve as the surface area of the diaphragm is greater than that of our piston, thus the stiffer spring that still doesn't hold as well as ours.
If your car doesn't seem to respond as well with the Forge valve look for the following:
Loose cap
Loose flange
Loose side port
Perform the "pen-test"
http://www.forgemotorsport.com/media/valve_service(1).pdf
Check for leaks, especially anywhere that was effected by the install - manifold reference line, where the valve couples with the charge pipe, discharge hose to the turbo inlet pipe