I have been running The BFG G-Force KDW 215-45-ZR17, amazing grip, I would say the grip outclasses the stock suspension, so now I am looking to upgrade to coilovers, and potentially bigger sway bars. Wet traction awesome (when there is any tread left), Never drive in the cold (Bay Area, CA), Can't hear the tires over my motor mounts and exhaust, and I put new tires on the back every 5k, and move the rears to the front.
One quick question, why would somebody buy one of the best handling production cars ever built, then put a set of the worst tires ever made on that same car? It is akin to ordering a steak and only eating the garnish. The MSP is not economical, practical, or convenient, when originally sold, it was head and shoulders above anything on the market in terms of handling, trying to make it something it is not seems counterproductive. Feed and care of sports cars is an expensive endeavor, if you don't have the desire to pay the price, they made the Protege`5 for you.