Hey, if you drive like a granny (defeating the purpose of a fun car like the P5), and don't at all care about being prepared for the inevitable (accident avoidance), use the door psi.
As with everything, there's trickle-down. Just because you are not a power lifter doesn't mean you shouldn't use powerlifting techniques to increase progress in the gym; just because you aren't a marathon runner or sprinter doesn't mean you shouldn't train like one for fitness; and just because you never push the limits in your car, doesn't mean you shouldn't be prepared to. Take notes from people who do those things, and benefit from their experience. Don't take my word for it; ask a racer/autox'er.
You assume the auto maker knows best. You're right, they know best for 1) their own pockets, and 2) their intended target demographic. I sold VW's for a while, and here's what sells: "ooo, see how solid the door *sounds* when it closes?"; "yeah, hit that divot in the road faster, see, I bet your piece of crap has a lot more rattles and sqeaks, you NEED this car". Mazda specs a tire pressure in those lines: soft, quiet, comfortable, but still safe-ish in a majority of conditions. This equals sales.
If auto makers were about ultimate safety and performance, there'd be no aftermarket. Fact is, *we* CAN make our cars handle better than Mazda; we're not saddled with marketing and bean-counter issues. So go up the pressure and throw a fat rear sway on there!
I am a racer and have done auto cross several times. My one uncle owns a race team with three vintage triumph TR-4s and one TR-5, which I drove quite often as the registered driver for events. He's 60 years old and we restored the cars ourselfs. My other uncle owned a very good auto repair service station for over 40 years, and my father use to drag race on a semi-pro level. So please do not tell me I do not know what I am talking about.
I agree that a high performance tire does a stiffer side wall and much better construction there for you can run a slightly higher tire pressure in those tires for track and let's call it spirited driving. A cheap all condition tire will "roll" more and is not made for aggressive driving because of the softer side wall and more comfort designed tread patter, but by over inflating a cheap tire to compensate for the lack of built in performance you are decreasing the foot print of the tire and there in decreasing the performance that tire is capable of.
When im at the track we are always checking and changing our tire pressure thru out the day depending on conditions to get optimal feel and results for the way I drive the car. Every car is a slight bit different and every person drives there car slighty differently. About once a month I check my tire pressure on on my cars when there cold in the morning and set the tire preasure to the recommended psi +/- 1psi for error. In the winter I will usually put in about 2+ psi cause I know the tires and air won't be heating up that much when it's 20 degrees out side and the summer I leave it where Mazda recommends unless I know I'm going to be driving the car harder.
Let's just say this and be done with it. The sticker recommondations are a good place to start and will work for most people in most conditions. If you drive a bit more spirited then increase your pressure as you wish. Do not exceed the Max tire pressure that it on your current tires. That max will change from tire to tire because some tires are better constructed then others. If you have a cheapo set of all seasons don't expect to drive like a friggin master track star, get a better set of tires that are designed for those conditons. If you drive in the winter get a set of winter tires they make a huge difference, Follow the same guidlines as above. Generally speaking a narrower tire IS what you want for drive IN SNOW. 2-3" of fresh snow a narrower tire will "cut thru the snow better and get down to the pavement to provide better traction. It's a snow plow effect, a wide snow tire is like taking the width of a snow plow and trying to shovel with it, a human would not be able to that, a narrower snow tire is like a regular shovel, much easyier to move the snow out of the way. Now that was for driving IN SNOW, if you drive ON SNOW, like we often had in wisconsin where I lived until last year the story can be a little different. When there is very heavy snow fall and you are driving on top of the snow there is no way your tires will get down to the actuall pavement so a lower tire preasure will widen your tire foot print slightly as long as you are driving at slower speeds as you should be in such conditons. Now, if you do find your self stuck, one trick that I learned is to let almost all the air out of tire so that it get's really wide and flat, then slowly, VERY VERY SLOWLY drive out of the hole your in, you do not want to spin the tires in this situation as it will pack the snow and make it even slicker. Once your unstuck reinflate your tires and be on your way again.
Now, everyone may not agree with me on this and argue up and down about it. All I know is that it has worked several times in the past for me including recently in late december here in portland area when we got something like 15-17" in a two week period.
Take it or leave it that's up to you. Just drive smart, and have fun out there.(drive)
P.S. I'm really not trying to piss people of here. Just telling it like I see it. And like anything in this world, consider all sides, form your own opinion, and be respectfull to others. Then do what YOU want to do with the information out there.
Love and peace to all Mazda Zoomers out there, I'm out.