ive got the CPE catless downpipe mated to a 3" into 2.5" custom cat back with generic flowmaster style mufflers. Its not overly loud, and i think my CEL has popped once for not having cats. i guess im lucky because 80% of everyone else with a catless downpipe has CELs out the ass. as far as power gains, exhaust made a huge difference. before that i only had a Injen CAI and when i did the DP and cat back together, i really noticed a difference. Ive got an AP waiting at home for me too so once i tune i can only imagine how much better its gonna get. I will warn you, the DP swap is a little bit in depth. One thing that did help me as far as making more room was to support the engine/tranny with a jack, un bolt the passenger motor mount and then SLOWLY ease the jack down. this caused the engine to tilt forward slightly so i was able to remove the stock DP and #1 cat together through the top. that way you can just unbolt the #2 cat from the bottom. also, some of the heat shields can be a PITA since the bolts that hold them on are most likely rusted to the heat shield and will either resist or just snap off. Either way, i left the heat shields off once the new DP was on. oh and if you dont have them, swivel attachments for sockets, wd40/zep/pb blaster and an impact gun make this WORLDS easier.
If i had to vouch for one it would be the CPE obviously. The ATP is a v-band style so it wont work with the stock turbo unless you get the V-band adapter from ATP (it may be included but i dont remember). corksport makes a nice piece and i was actually debating between that one or CPEs. It just so happened that the corksport was out of stock at the moment so i got the CPE.