May Photography Contest - Voting Thread
- Thread starter yashart_mp3
- Start date
yashart_mp3
Member
- :
- Black Mica MS3
Sorry for the delay guys. I needed to stop and think about the direction the contest is going. I have also been talking to Truc and a few of the other members here behind the scene trying to figure out the best resolution for all of this.
First, by my decision alone, Truc is the winner of this months contest. Whats done has already been done. I am sure that others have requested votes from friends in contests before this. Unfortunately for Truc, he had more success with this than anyone else who may have tried this, and he got called out on it. Because he was upfront, honest, and was mature about everything, I see no reason why he shouldn't be the winner. If anyone has an issue with this, then bring it up with me directly, as this was 100% my decision. Please note however, these types of actions really hurt the photo contest. Look at the hamper it has put on this months contest. I hope, if for nothing else, it will be an example to discourage people from doing this in the future.
Now, to comment on some other things. I dont know if some of you guys misread my first post, but as I said, the date the photo was taken is irrelevant for this month and all previous contests. And I quote myself "Since this was never an official rule of the contest, there is nobody at fault for this. I cannot expect you guys to follow something that was never formally voiced. This is something that I would simply like to change for future contests." Although it may be difficult for people to get out and take pictures every month, this is still going to be a rule that implement from here on out. Take me for example. I have not been able to go out and takes pics for the last couple of contests....so I simply have not entered the contest, rather than submit one of the thousands of previously taken images I have on my computer. If you cannot or do not have the time to go out with your camera and snap some pics, there is always another contest right around the corner. What Im really looking to accomplish with this rule, is to remove the "hey, I have a photo that works, maybe I'll win some money". For most of us here, that isn't the case. I would rather see someone be rewarded for going out and take a picture relevant to the theme, rather than someone who saw the contest, looked on their computer for five minutes and picked a photo that works. I hope you guys can understand where I am coming from with this. I will also do my best to make sure that everyone will be able to participate, taking into consideration location, weather, etc.
As for the contest photo submissions, they will stay as is for now. I like to think that people are honest and fair, so we give this method another shot. If it somehow starts to drift to a popularity contest, then the format will be changed. if that does not solve the issue, then I will no longer fund the contest and prizes will be up to the donations received to purchase the prizes (currently $0). I would hate to see the contest come to this, and I honestly don't think it will. Everyone here seems to thoroughly enjoy the contest. You have no idea how many people have told me they are getting into photography and asking for advice on what cameras to get, so that they can get involved as well! So the contest is doing exactly what we all had hoped it would do. As long as everyone does their part to keep things honest and fair (as you have all been doing), we'll be fine. None of us want to see this come to an end. Keep up the good work guys and gals.
Lastly, this months topic will be posted sometime after lunch
First, by my decision alone, Truc is the winner of this months contest. Whats done has already been done. I am sure that others have requested votes from friends in contests before this. Unfortunately for Truc, he had more success with this than anyone else who may have tried this, and he got called out on it. Because he was upfront, honest, and was mature about everything, I see no reason why he shouldn't be the winner. If anyone has an issue with this, then bring it up with me directly, as this was 100% my decision. Please note however, these types of actions really hurt the photo contest. Look at the hamper it has put on this months contest. I hope, if for nothing else, it will be an example to discourage people from doing this in the future.
Now, to comment on some other things. I dont know if some of you guys misread my first post, but as I said, the date the photo was taken is irrelevant for this month and all previous contests. And I quote myself "Since this was never an official rule of the contest, there is nobody at fault for this. I cannot expect you guys to follow something that was never formally voiced. This is something that I would simply like to change for future contests." Although it may be difficult for people to get out and take pictures every month, this is still going to be a rule that implement from here on out. Take me for example. I have not been able to go out and takes pics for the last couple of contests....so I simply have not entered the contest, rather than submit one of the thousands of previously taken images I have on my computer. If you cannot or do not have the time to go out with your camera and snap some pics, there is always another contest right around the corner. What Im really looking to accomplish with this rule, is to remove the "hey, I have a photo that works, maybe I'll win some money". For most of us here, that isn't the case. I would rather see someone be rewarded for going out and take a picture relevant to the theme, rather than someone who saw the contest, looked on their computer for five minutes and picked a photo that works. I hope you guys can understand where I am coming from with this. I will also do my best to make sure that everyone will be able to participate, taking into consideration location, weather, etc.
As for the contest photo submissions, they will stay as is for now. I like to think that people are honest and fair, so we give this method another shot. If it somehow starts to drift to a popularity contest, then the format will be changed. if that does not solve the issue, then I will no longer fund the contest and prizes will be up to the donations received to purchase the prizes (currently $0). I would hate to see the contest come to this, and I honestly don't think it will. Everyone here seems to thoroughly enjoy the contest. You have no idea how many people have told me they are getting into photography and asking for advice on what cameras to get, so that they can get involved as well! So the contest is doing exactly what we all had hoped it would do. As long as everyone does their part to keep things honest and fair (as you have all been doing), we'll be fine. None of us want to see this come to an end. Keep up the good work guys and gals.
Lastly, this months topic will be posted sometime after lunch
Last edited:
yashart_mp3
Member
- :
- Black Mica MS3
a quick update:
Although Truc is was official winner for this month, he has declined the win and prize money, and has offered to donate to the contest as well. " I'll pitch in $10 and won't claim this month's winnings. I just can't win this way. It's not right. " He is truly sorry, and wishes to make things right. Truc is a good guy. Thanks again buddy. So for this month, there will be no official winner. Hopefully now we can all move on and get back to snapping some good pictures!
Although Truc is was official winner for this month, he has declined the win and prize money, and has offered to donate to the contest as well. " I'll pitch in $10 and won't claim this month's winnings. I just can't win this way. It's not right. " He is truly sorry, and wishes to make things right. Truc is a good guy. Thanks again buddy. So for this month, there will be no official winner. Hopefully now we can all move on and get back to snapping some good pictures!
Last edited:
yashart_mp3 said:
Very classy move Truc. Big props to Ya!
Amen to snapping some good pics! My camera is charged and ready to go!
Sidenote to all forum members who participarte in photo contest: We've got a good thing going here people. Something to give us all a break from detonating motors, oil changes, tire sizes and such. Its something fun that anyone can participate in and I'd hate to see it go down the crapper.
I still think a lot of folks like to participate (I usually submit my shot close to the deadline so I don't end up with a "me-too" shot like what happened with my flower shot. But I'll be participating in this contest until I leave the forums or the contest is no more.
Thanks for the cool thread Yashart.
Last edited:
I support yashart's decision 100% and praise the leadership he showed while adjudicating this issue. I also give a pat on the back to the other contestants, especially truc, who kept emotion out of this voting thread.
I think the rules for the contest, as amended, will lead to better entries and a more meaningful contest for everyone.
I think the rules for the contest, as amended, will lead to better entries and a more meaningful contest for everyone.
yashart_mp3
Member
- :
- Black Mica MS3
Turned in my 20-page social research paper yesterday, so I'm officially done with school! (for a 2 weeks before the summer term kicks in). Anywho, the June contest is up. Sorry for the delay once again. I'll try to do a better job of keeping the photo contests on a steady and consistent pace
yashart_mp3 said:Turned in my 20-page social research paper yesterday, so I'm officially done with school! (for a 2 weeks before the summer term kicks in). Anywho, the June contest is up. Sorry for the delay once again. I'll try to do a better job of keeping the photo contests on a steady and consistent pace
You better, or we'll come find ya!(gun)
Just kidding!
Rednecks_wife
Sweet 50 on AZMC
- :
- 1966 Mustang (gone-but only down the street) 1950 Chevy Truck
yashart_mp3 said:
That's why Truc is so highly respected within the Arizona Mazda Club.
You do Man.
- :
- '04 RX8
So I guess there is no june contest?
