Will be needing tires on our 19 Signature soon - what's the current word on replacement brands/models? Will be checking out Tire Rack reviews but figured I'd ask here. Have oem Toyos and won't go with them again. Kinda partial to General Altimax from past cars. Thanks
As others have mentioned, it kind of depends.
How important is:
1) Price
2) Wet weather traction
3) Dry weather traction
4) Snow/ice traction
5) Ride comfort
6) Noise level
7) Tire wear
8) Etc.
Assuming you want to keep the same size (225/55R19)...
If you want UHP or Max performance summer, then you cannot go wrong with the Michelin Pilot Sport 4. Great price on those too the last time I looked. I've run them on a 370z and they performed very well. Don't last that long though.
Going to the other extreme, if you are more interested in an all season tire that sees a lot of snow, then folks seem to like the Michelin Crossclimate2.
Going in between for UHP that doesn't see much snow, but is just fine with a little, the Michelin Pilot Sport All Season is hard to beat.
If you are just looking for a touring tire and want to save a bit of money, there is a Pirelli Scorpion that people seem to like.
Again, that's all if you stay at the stock tire size.