To be honest, I've been thinking back about that trip and I remember it showing over 40mpg on the return and I decided to make sure and calculate the mpg because I didn't believe the computer. I was wondering at the time if the wind shifted direction mid-day giving me favorable winds going both directions. The winds were kind of 'shifty' that day and driving along the front range mountains you can encounter weird crosswinds, etc., so I think that is very possible. \
I know from experience I would be lucky to get 30 mpg if I encounter headwinds. I usually slow down a bit as I don't know how else to handle them. I still might be getting 27 mpg for the worst parts.
I was looking at the owner's manual on how to operate the manual transmission and noticed it only has a page and a half on how to operate it. The section on how to operate the automatic is over six pages!